Save this article to read it later.

Find this story in your accountsSaved for Latersection.

In 1969, Paul Mazurskys movieBob & Carol & Ted & Alicewas a runaway hit.

Article image

Baby, could itever.

Much of the original plot is there.

Staring deep into each others eyes, they see vulnerability and permission.

Carol tries to explain: Bob, its where wereat.Its how wefeel.

The world has not been clamoring for a musicalization of Mazurskys film, which has certainly fought the process.

And third, the film alreadyhadmemorable music.

Erasing good stuff and replacing it with Sheiks shag-carpet-soft rock isnt a good trade.

At the end of the film, after an anticlimactic (hello!)

Certainly, despite Scott Elliotts typically careful direction, there is a sizzle of instability in the air.

Would that have been darker and truer?

Her slightly awkward, not-an-actor coolness, though, puts the effortful central foursome in stark relief.

The rest spend the show clearly ill at ease.

Perhaps their discomfort stems from the way that Elliotts in-the-round environment gives them nowhere to hide.

But the show just keeps turning them off.

Bob & Carol & Ted & Aliceis at the Pershing Square Signature Center through March 22.